In the late 1950s, the Chinese people were decimated by a catastrophic famine. The death toll, which was obscured by the Chinese government, is a matter of historical debate. The consensus is that around 30 million people died, though estimates range from 10 million to as high as 47 million.
With its large population and volatile agrarian economy, China was no stranger to famine. Its agricultural productivity was easily disrupted and susceptible to climate events, natural disasters, population changes and military conflict.
The Great Chinese Famine, as the famine of 1958-61 is often known, was deadlier than both combined. The causes and outcomes of the Great Famine are partially obscured and subject to considerable debate. Though caused chiefly by drought and weather conditions, the Great Famine was undoubtedly worsened by the communist policies.
According to the government and the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), the Great Famine was caused by a string of natural disasters. Communist historiography refers to it not as the Great Famine but the “Three Years of Natural Disasters”.
There is certainly some truth in this claim. In mid-1959, the Yellow River (or Huang Ho) flooded, causing thousands of drownings and ruined crops. According to government reports, more than 40 million hectares (almost 100 million acres) of agricultural land were rendered useless.
These floods were followed by a wave of further disasters: droughts, severe heat, more floods, typhoons, disease and insect infestations.
In 1959, drought caused significant crop failures in Shaanxi (where output declined by more than 50 per cent) and Hubei (where it fell by 25 per cent). The following year Shanxi, Hebei, Shandong and Henan provinces suffered prolonged droughts, their production falling by more than half.
China’s southern and coastal provinces also endured 11 major typhoons. In 1961, the northern provinces again suffered months of drought, while those in the south endured more flooding.
While these disasters and climate events are confirmed by independent meteorological data, their real impact on agricultural production is also open to debate.
Most Western historians agree that failed government policies and human mismanagement were more culpable than natural disasters. Frank Dikötter describes China’s starving millions as the “unintended consequences of half-baked and poorly executed economic programmes”.
The British historian John K. Fairbank describes the heavy loss of life as “a Mao-made catastrophe… an all-time, first-class, man-made famine”. Even some of Mao Zedong’s contemporaries agreed.
Speaking in 1962, the economic moderate Liu Shaoqi attributed the Great Famine to 70 per cent renhuo (human error) and 30 per cent tianzai (natural disasters).
Agrarian policy and Lysenko
The massive structural changes and labour redistribution of the Great Leap Forward placed the farming peasantry under enormous strain.
Several historians point to the fact that the adverse weather events were fairly localised. In 1959, only 9.6 per cent of farmland was reported as unusable by local officials – yet this became the worst year of the famine.
Another factor in China’s slumping agricultural production were the theories of Trofim Lysenko, a Soviet agronomist.
Just as Marxism hoped to reinvent society, Lysenko wanted to revolutionise farming by discarding existing knowledge in favour of new techniques. Many of Lysenko’s theories were flawed and his new agricultural methods did more harm than good.
Lysenko had been largely discredited in his native Russia, however, Mao Zedong ordered collective farms to employ many of his ideas. Farmers were ordered to ‘close-plant’ (sowing millions of seeds of different species together in a small area) and ‘deep-plough’ (digging the ground much deeper to encourage deep root growth). Both these experiments failed and entire plantings yielded next to nothing.
Farmers were also forbidden to use chemical fertilisers and large amounts of land were left fallow, with poor results. Lysenko’s crackpot theories compounded the crop failures caused by adverse weather.
Reports and requisitioning
Many Western historians believe that local officials grossly exaggerated the effects of these natural disasters in their statistics and reports to Beijing. This was done to conceal or justify low production in their region, to appease the communist government or to obtain tax relief or assistance.
Some researchers also claim that figures from 1959-61 were knowingly distorted by the national government, in order to hide the failings of its own policies, particularly the Great Leap Forward.
A more tangible cause of famine was grain procurement by the state. From 1953, all Chinese farmers were required to sell grain to the government at prices and levels decided by the government. Some of this grain was redistributed back to the farmers. Most, however, was either sent to the cities (the so-called ‘urban food bias’), sold as export grain or distributed as foreign aid, to create the illusion of a booming economy.
The following table, based on data from Li and Yang (2005), shows that while grain production fell between 1959 and 1961, grain procurement remained disproportionately high. In the first two years of the famine, grain output plummeted by 15 per cent (1959) and 29 per cent (1960) – yet the government still carted away more than one third of grain produced:
|Grain per capita
(kilogram per person)
Food shortages increase
With the state commandeering such high levels of grain, communes were left with insufficient food grain of their own. Some communes ignored the problem and maintained full rations, believing things would improve or the government would send food relief.
By the summer of 1959, however, food shortages had reached a critical point. Relief should have come at the Lushan conference (August 1959), where the ambitious targets of the Great Leap Forward and the over-reporting of grain production were both criticised by Peng Dehuai. Mao Zedong’s response was to attack his critics rather than relax his policies.
In the countryside, meanwhile, the peasants began to starve. Many sought alternative food sources like grass, sawdust, leather, even seeds sifted from animal manure. In Sichuan, thousands of peasants were forced to eat soil. Dogs, cats, rats, mice and insects were all eaten, dead or alive, until there were no more.
Malnutrition, famine oedema (swelling) and the effects of vitamin deficiency became apparent. The birth rate plummeted as peasant women suffered increased levels of amenorrhea (absence of menstrual periods) and prolapsed uterus, caused by weakening pelvic muscles. Unsurprisingly, mental illness, hysteria and suicide were also common. Between two and three million people are believed to have taken their own lives during the famine years.
One of the grisliest effects of the Great Famine was cannibalism. Nobody knows how often or how widely it occurred but there are scores of accounts of flesh-eating, both official and anecdotal.
Police reports detail specific incidents of cannibalism. In Linxia, Gansu province, dozens of peasants were arrested in 1960, most for exhuming the corpses of their neighbours and eating them “to survive”. There were 1,289 cases of cannibalism reported in Anhui province that same year.
Chang and Halliday tell of a husband and wife in Fengyang who strangled and devoured their eight-year-old son. Other parents exchanged children so they would not have to carry the shame of eating their own. Instances of cannibalism were severely punished by the authorities but continued regardless.
There were also many cases of child abandonment, child selling and forced prostitution. Some starving peasants murdered their children, elderly relatives or spouses as an act of kindness, to end their starving misery.
Propaganda and concealment
The CCP government concealed the extent of the famine, both from its own people in the cities and from the rest of the world. Food supplies in the cities had also dwindled, causing death rates in some urban centres to double; this was attributed to natural disasters.
Despite these problems, China continued to export grain through 1959 and 1960, sending some seven million tons of grain offshore – an amount that could have saved as many as 16 million lives. After hearing reports of the famine, the International Red Cross offered food aid but this was refused by Beijing.
The government suppressed all information about the famine. Movement out of affected regions was banned, while mail and other communication were prohibited or censored.
CCP propaganda posters continued to celebrate the Great Leap Forward by showing fertile fields, bountiful harvests and happy, healthy peasants. One state department produced a propaganda film suggesting that Chinese peasants were prospering, showing one commune with fat, healthy livestock and full granaries. The reality, of course, was starkly different.
A historian’s view:
“Mao received numerous reports about hunger, disease and abuse from every corner of the country: personal letters mailed by courageous individuals, unsolicited complaints from local cadres, or investigations undertaken on his behalf by security personnel or private secretaries… By the end of 1958, Mao did make a few gestures to appease concern about widespread abuse on the ground… Mao did slow down the pace of the Great Leap Forward between November 1958 and June 1959, but he was unwavering in his pursuit of utopia.”
1. The Great Famine or Great Chinese Famine was a period of low agricultural production, food shortages and mass starvation in China, from 1959 to 1961.
2. The CCP government attributes the famine to natural disasters such as droughts, floods, typhoons and pests. While these undoubtedly contributed, human error and the flawed policies of the Great Leap Forward worsened the effects of the famine.
3. Some of the other causes mentioned by historians include the failed agronomic methods of Trofim Lysenko, over-reporting by both local officials and the national government, and the excessive procurement of grain by the state.
4. By late 1959 food shortages of critical and signs of famine were visible in many provinces. The peasants tried to survive by seeking alternative food sources and even resorting to acts of cannibalism.
5. The CCP government suppressed information and statistics about the famine so the total death toll has never been accurately calculated. The consensus is that around 30 million people died, though some historians have suggested as many as 45 million perished.