What is history?




historyHistory is the study of the past, particularly people and events of the past. History is a pursuit common to all human societies. Human beings have always been interested in the past, for many reasons. History is a tremendous story, a rolling narrative filled with great personalities, struggle and suffering, turmoil and triumph. Each passing generation adds its own chapter to history, while reinterpreting and finding new things in those chapters already written. History also gives us a sense of identity, helping us to understand who we are. History provides a sense of context for our lives and our existence, teaching us where we have come from and how we should approach the future. History shows us what it means to be human and highlights the tremendous achievements and the great follies of the human race. History also gives us lessons about how we should organise and manage our societies, for the betterment of all.




Those starting out in history often consider history and the past to be the same thing. This is not the case. The past refers to an earlier time, the people and societies who inhabited it and the events that took place there. History describes our attempts at investigating, studying and explaining the past. It is a subtle difference but an important one. What happened in the past is fixed in time and cannot be changed. History, however, changes regularly. The word “history” and the English word “story” both originate from the Latin historia, meaning a narrative or account of past events. History is itself a collection of thousands of stories about the past, told by many different people. Because there are so many stories, they are often variable, contradictory and conflicting. And like all stories, history is subject to revision and reinterpretation. Each generation looks at the past in its own way, applying different standards, priorities and values. The study of how history differs and has changed over time is called historiography.

Like historical narratives themselves, our understanding of what history is and what shape it should take is flexible and open to disagreement. For as long as people have studied history, historians have nursed different ideas about how history should be studied, constructed, written and interpreted. Historians therefore approach history in different ways, using different ideas and methods and focusing on different things. The links below contain several popular theories of history utilised by well known historians:

History is the study of great individuals
plutarch historian
Plutarch
According to the ancient Greek writer Plutarch, history is chiefly the product of great leaders and innovators. Prominent individuals shape the course of history through their personality, strength of character, ambition, abilities, leadership or creativity. Plutarch’s histories were written almost as biographies or ‘life and times’ stories of these great individuals; he explained how the actions of these great figures shaped the course of their nations or societies. This approach served as a model for many later historians. It is often referred to as ‘top down’ history, because of its focus on rulers or leaders. One advantage to this approach is its accessibility and relative easiness. It is generally much easier to research and write about individuals than social movements or complex factors. This focus on individuals also tends to be more interesting and accessible to readers. The main problem with Plutarch’s approach is that it can sidestep, simplify or overlook historical factors and conditions that do not emanate from important individuals.

History is the study of the 'winds of change'
history
The Berlin Wall falls in 1989, a ‘winds of change’ moment
Other historians have focused less on individuals and taken a more thematic approach, looking at factors and forces that produce significant historical change. Some have looked at what might broadly be described as the ‘winds of change’: powerful ideas, forces and movements that shape or affect how people live, work and think. These great ideas and movements are often initiated or driven by influential people – but they soon become much larger forces for change. As the ‘winds of change’ strengthen and grow they shape or influence political, economic and social events and conditions. One notable ‘wind of change’ was Christianity, which shaped government, society and social customs in medieval Europe. Another was the European Enlightenment, which undermined old ideas about politics, religion and the natural world, and triggered a long period of curiosity, education and innovation. Marxism emerged in the late 19th century and grew to challenge the old order in Russia, China and elsewhere, shaping government and society in those nations. The Age of Exploration, the Industrial Revolution, decolonisation in the mid 1900s and the winding back of eastern European communism in the late 1900s are all tangible examples of the ‘winds of change’.

History is the study of challenge and response
history
The Roman Empire’s failure to meet certain challenges led to its decline
Some historians, such as the British writer Arnold Toynbee (1889-1975), believed that historical change is driven by challenges and responses. All civilisations are defined not just by their leadership or conditions, but by how they respond to difficult problems or crises. These challenges take many forms. They can be physical, environmental, economic or ideological; they can derive from internal pressures or external factors; they can come from their own people or from outsiders. The survival and success of a civilisation is often determined by how it responds to these challenges. This itself often depends on its people and how creative, resourceful, adaptable and flexible they are. Human history is filled with many tangible examples of challenge and response. Many nations have been confronted with powerful rivals, wars, natural disasters, economic slumps, new ideas, emerging political movements and internal dissent. The process of colonisation, for example, involved major challenges, both for colonising settlers and native inhabitants. Economic changes, such as new technologies and increases or decreases in trade, can create challenges in the form of social changes or class tensions.

History is the study of dialectics
history
Karl Marx, creator of the ‘material dialectic’
In philosophical terms, dialectics is the process where two or more parties resolve disagreements through rational discussion, compromise and mutual agreement. The concept of dialectics was applied to history by German philosopher Georg Hegel (1770-1831). Hegel suggested that most historical changes and outcomes were driven by dialectic interaction. According to Hegel, for every thesis (a proposition or ‘idea’) there exists an antithesis (a reaction or ‘opposite idea’). The thesis and antithesis encounter or struggle, from which emerges a synthesis (a ‘new idea’). This ongoing process of struggle and development reveals new ideas and new truths to humanity. The German philosopher Karl Marx (1818-1883) was a student of Hegel and incorporated the Hegelian dialectic into his own theory of history – but with one important distinction. According to Marx, history was shaped by the ‘material dialectic’: the struggle between economic classes. Marx believed that economic factors underpinned most social structures and interactions. All classes struggle and push to improve their economic condition, Marx wrote, usually at the expense of other classes. Marx’s material dialectic was reflected in his stinging criticisms of capitalism, a political and economic system where the ruling classes own and control the means of production.

History is the story of the unexpected
history
Franz Ferdinand’s murder in 1914, an unexpected but pivotal moment in history
Some historians believe that history is shaped by the accidental, the surprising and the unexpected. While history and historical change often follow patterns, they can also be unpredictable and chaotic. For all our fascination with timelines and linear progression, history does not always follow a clear and expected path. The past is filled with unexpected incidents, surprises and accidental discoveries. Some of these have unleashed historical forces and changes that could not be predicted, controlled or stopped. A few have come at pivotal times and served as the ignition or ‘flashpoint’ for changes of great significance. The discovery of gold has triggered ‘gold rushes’ that have shaped the future of entire nations. In June 1914 Archduke Franz Ferdinand’s car took a different route through Sarajevo and ended up passing an aimless Gavrilo Princip, a confluence of events that changed the course of history. American historian Daniel Boorstin (1914-2004), an exponent of this fascination with historical accidents, claimed that if Cleopatra’s nose had been shorter, thus diminishing her beauty, then the history of the world might have been radically different.





© Alpha History 2014. Content on this page may not be republished or distributed without permission. For more information please refer to our Terms of Use.
This page was written by Jennifer Llewellyn, Jim Southey and Steve Thompson. To reference this page, use the following citation:
J. Llewellyn et al, “What is history?” at Alpha History, http://alphahistory.com/what-is-history/, 2014, accessed [date of last access].